Hi all. It’s that time of year again when everybody starts frantically looking for awesome turkey recipes and the best cooking methods online. Why not try something different this time around and use your Traeger Pellet Grill to slow-smoke your Thanksgiving Turkey? Traeger Smoked Thanksgiving Turkey is one of my family’s favorites, so I wanted to share with you my tips and tricks to make your Thanksgiving feast simple yet unforgettable.
If you’re like my family and me and love the flavor of a smoked Thanksgiving turkey, or have always wanted to try it, then read on. There is something here for both the beginner and experienced cook; I promise you, it is easier than you think. A Turkey is one of the easier things to smoke in my humble opinion and it is FANTASTIC!
In This Article, We’ll Explore:
Click a topic below to be taken directly to that section.
The Advantages of Smoking Your Turkey on the Traeger
Not only does slow smoking your turkey help keep the meat super juicy, but it also infuses that awesome smoky hardwood flavor by using your favorite variety of wood pellets. Another great thing about cooking your Turkey outdoors is that it frees up your oven for all the other mouthwatering side creations your family and friends expect.
Perhaps the only downside is that your house will not have that heavenly roasted turkey smell until you bring it in the house. But don’t worry, the smoked turkey aroma will definitely make up for the lost time.
Quick Story About Last Year’s Traeger Smoked Thanksgiving Turkey
We actually didn’t even host at our house last year as we were invited to a family member’s house. We were informed that they would be serving a honey-baked ham with all the trimmings. Ok, I could deal with that I guess, although I was feeling a little bummed that I wouldn’t be able to smoke a turkey that year.
I really enjoy smoking a full turkey and the flavor can be amazing but it’s something I mostly only do once a year for Thanksgiving. I am always meaning to do it more throughout the year, but after the leftover turkey burnout from the holiday, it always slips off my radar.
My Second Chance at Traeger Smoked Turkey
So while I was feeling down and making a promise to myself that I would definitely smoke a turkey the following month to make up for it, we received a call from the hosts. They asked if I would mind smoking a turkey and bringing it when we came. They said they know how much everyone loved my turkeys in the past and it would be great to have it to go along with the ham.
While trying not to let on to my sudden excitement, I replied as casually as I could, “sure, I guess I can do that”.
And so it was on!
I started planning right away, making sure my equipment was ready, deciding on my recipe, and gathering all the ingredients. Thankfully, there was still time for a dry brine.
Should Brine Your Turkey?
Oh, did I forget to mention brining? Well, let me fill you in on a little secret. The absolute best way to smoke a turkey is to brine it first. If you don’t know what brining is, you can check out this article, How To Brine Meat – An Intro And Guide To Brining.
The following smoked turkey recipe starts out with a super simple dry brining process. My preferred method is a dry brine, but whether you choose the dry or wet method, I highly recommend adding this step.
Why You Should Dry Brine Your Turkey Instead of Wet Brining
A dry brine will help you skip the hassle and mess of a wet brine.
Why deal with the messy water version when dry brining is just as effective if not more so in my opinion. Dry brining is not only easier, but it also produces better flavor because the natural juices aren’t diluted or replaced by the water.
Instead of soaking up all the extra water when you wet brine, a dry brine tenderizes and helps preserve the turkey’s juices without watering down the flavor. Here are two helpful articles on the subject to help you decide and get you going.
Once you’ve gotten your brine on, it’s time to work on the turkey recipe because smoked Thanksgiving turkey never tasted so good!
Traeger Smoked Thanksgiving Turkey Recipe
I started with a beautifully fresh and unfrozen organic 15-pound turkey and boy was I lucky to get it. As I said, it was pretty last minute (the day before Thanksgiving) and it was the last one left at that size that was not frozen.
I decided to go with a simple, tried, and true recipe this year because of the time frame I had to work with. This is not to say that it is a bad recipe because it is still one of my favorites, but I usually like to experiment and try new ideas.
A quick rundown of the recipe is below.
Turkey Recipe Ingredients
I went with a rosemary, lemon, and garlic seasoning that I have used many times before on whole chickens and turkeys. A quick rundown of the recipe is below.
- 10 fresh rosemary sprigs
- 3 tablespoons chopped fresh rosemary leaves
- 5 fresh thyme sprigs
- Chopped Shallots
- 10 cloves garlic, peeled
- 5 cloves garlic, minced
- 1 onion, peeled and cut into 1-inch chunks
- 2 healthy-sized lemons, cut into 1-inch chunks
- 1 tablespoon shredded lemon peel
- 1/3 cup olive oil or softened butter (I used butter on mine)
- 1 teaspoon coarse-ground pepper
- Salt for flavor
- 2 cups of chicken broth
Start by removing the giblets and rinsing the turkey inside and out. Pat it dry with paper towels. Load up the turkey’s belly with the rosemary sprigs, thyme sprigs, cut lemons, peeled garlic cloves, and onion chunks.
You then mix the remaining ingredients into a mixing bowl and smash them together with the butter. Rub and massage the bird from top to bottom with the butter mix, taking care to coat every inch of skin to make sure every bite is loaded with flavor. I try and rub as much as I can under the skin as well, but that is not really necessary. The flavor will still get in. I also sprinkle extra rosemary over the outside of the bird for extra flavor.
Next, fill your roasting pan with the chicken broth, and you’re ready to go.
Smoking the Turkey on the Traeger
I decided to use the Traeger pellet grill this year instead of my Big Green Egg porcelain smoker. The main reason was that I had to start smoking the bird at 5 am due to an early dinner start time and the Traeger is a very easy to use option compared to charcoal smoking. You can literally set your desired temperature on the Traeger, insert a wireless meat probe with automatic alerts and go back to bed if you wanted to.
Into the Traeger, our bird went with the setting on smoke for the first 3 hours. Give that bird and good long smoke, letting the grill do all the work while you get busy on other things.
When three hours were up, I moved the temperature to the 350°F setting and let her cook until she reached a 165°F internal temperature. This took close to another 4 hours for the turkey to reach the proper and safe temperature. I basted the bird about once every hour during this later part.
Since the turkey is always the center of attention for every Thanksgiving meal, ensure that the meat is cooked perfectly by using a wireless meat probe and instant read thermometer.
I can’t even begin to tell you how much simpler your life will be using a good wireless remote meat thermometer for long cooks. I have reviewed several great remote temperature probe options you can read about here: The 10 Best Wireless Digital Meat Thermometers.
Finally, I wrapped the whole roasting pan, bird, and all in tin foil and then wrapped it again in towels for the ride to our family’s.
If you’re not transporting the bird, let it rest uncovered for 10-20minutes before carving. Covering it up with tin foil will make the skin less crisp.
Final Thoughts on Our Traeger Smoked Thanksgiving Turkey Recipe
I am happy to say that the Traeger smoked Thanksgiving turkey was a success. It was moist and dripping with juices. It had a nice and mild smoky flavor that went very well with the rosemary, lemon, and garlic recipe. And much to my delight and disappointment, there were no turkey leftovers to take home.
Oh well, looks like I will have to smoke another turkey next month after all. Darn! 🙂
Do you want the ULTIMATE Thanksgiving Turkey recipe? Check out The Mad Max Turkey Method for Roasting Turkey. This method and recipe are no joke.
I hope you have enjoyed my Thanksgiving turkey story and that you have a great Thanksgiving with your loved ones as well. If you try this recipe or have one of your own to share, we would love to hear about it in the comments below. If this was helpful to you, please consider sharing it with your friends or on social media. Sharing is caring my friends!
Now It’s Your Turn
I want to hear from you:
Do You Have a Helpful Tip to Share? Any
advice I May Have Missed? Questions?
Have you tried this recipe? I would love to hear you feedback.
Let me know by leaving a quick comment below.
If you still have questions, please feel free to send me a message.
Disclosure – At The Grilling Life, I am committed to researching and writing thoughtful, informative and editorially independent reviews of the best products for your outdoor cooking needs. If you like what I do, you can support me through my chosen links, which earn me a commission. This allows me to continue sharing with you my love for all things barbecue. Your support is truly appreciated.